As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. These links go to Amazon — if you buy, we get a small commission at no extra cost to you.
s, 12 Pack Simple Animal Paper Plate Crafts for Toddle New

Introduce your little ones to a world of creativity with our Arts and Crafts Kit, featuring a variety of colorful materials and projects designed to foster imagination and self-expression. With this kit, you'll be able to encourage your child's artistic side while enjoying quality time together, making memories that will last a lifetime.

Ages 2–5
View on Amazon
First Orchard Toddler Game New

"Introduce your little one to the joy of board games with My Very First Games: First Orchard, a delightful experience that fosters teamwork and excitement for young minds. This charming game is the perfect gift for toddlers who love exploring nature and learning through interactive play."

Age 2
View on Amazon
The Original Reversible Octopus Plushie

The Reversible Octopus is a soft and cuddly friend that changes from a bright blue octopus to a sunny yellow starfish with just one flip, providing endless entertainment for little ones. Made from high-quality materials and designed with safety in mind, this lovable companion is perfect for kids of all ages to snuggle, play, and learn with.

Ages 1–4

Our kids loved these immediately!

View on Amazon
Squishmallows Original 8in Blake The Bunny in Carrot Costume

Give your little one a cuddly companion to love with Squishmallows' adorable Blake The Bunny in Carrot Costume! This soft and snuggly friend is perfect for bedtime hugs, tea parties, or just having a playful adventure together.

Ages 1–4
View on Amazon
Gund Disney Eeyore

Bring joy to little ones' lives with Gund's lovable Disney Eeyore plush, perfect for cuddling up with during storytime or as a special companion in their own imagination-filled adventures. This soft and endearing friend will quickly become a treasured addition to any child's collection of beloved toys.

Ages 1–2
View on Amazon

Know a 2-year-old who loves animals?

Sign up free to track their birthday — we'll remind you before the day and surface fresh picks as they land.